TheLastGarden/.planning/phases/01-foundations-and-doctrine/01-VALIDATION.md

phase, slug, status, nyquist_compliant, wave_0_complete, created, updated, approval

phase	slug	status	nyquist_compliant	wave_0_complete	created	updated	approval
1	foundations-and-doctrine	executed (12 of 13 tasks green; 01-05-T2 partial — awaiting human curation of north-star images)	true	yes (all Wave 0 test infrastructure landed across Plans 01–06; CI workflow Plan 07 enforces the suite)	2026-05-08	2026-05-09 (per-task table populated by Plan 07 executor)	approved

Phase 1 — Validation Strategy

Per-phase validation contract for feedback sampling during execution. Source: 01-RESEARCH.md § Validation Architecture.

---

Test Infrastructure

Property	Value
Framework	Vitest 4.1.5 (verified 2026-05-08)
Config file	vitest.config.ts (Plan 01 Task 2 deliverable; environment: happy-dom)
Quick run command	npm test (alias for vitest run --passWithNoTests=false)
Full suite command	npm run ci (lint + test + validate-assets + build)
Estimated runtime	~5s quick, ~30s full

---

Sampling Rate

• After every task commit: Run npm test
• After every plan wave: Run npm run ci
• Before /gsd-verify-work: npm run ci must be green, plus manual smoke that npm run dev opens the Phaser scaffold
• Max feedback latency: ~5 seconds per commit, ~30 seconds per wave

---

Per-Task Verification Map

Populated by the planner during /gsd-plan-phase. Each task maps to a Wave 0 test stub or existing infrastructure.

Task ID	Plan	Wave	Requirement	Threat Ref	Secure Behavior	Test Type	Automated Command	File Exists	Status
01-01-T1	01	1	CORE-01	—	Scaffold builds	smoke	npm run build	✓ committed	✅ green
01-01-T2	01	1	(infra)	—	Vitest + Playwright wired	smoke	npm test && npx playwright --version	✓ committed	✅ green
01-02-T1	02	2	CORE-10	—	ESLint flat config + boundaries plugin in place	static-analysis	npm run lint	✓ committed	✅ green
01-02-T2	02	2	CORE-10	—	Boundary rule fires on sim → render import	unit (lint)	npx vitest run src/sim/__test_violation__/lint-firewall.test.ts	✓ committed	✅ green
01-03-T1	03	2	CORE-06, CORE-07	T-01-01	CRC-32 envelope + canonical JSON; v0→v1 synthetic migration	unit	npx vitest run src/save/checksum.test.ts src/save/envelope.test.ts src/save/migrations.test.ts	✓ committed	✅ green
01-03-T2	03	2	CORE-04, CORE-05, CORE-08	T-01-01	idb DB + LocalStorageDBAdapter fallback (CORE-04) + last-3 snapshot retention + persist API	unit	npx vitest run src/save/db.test.ts src/save/snapshots.test.ts src/save/persist.test.ts	✓ committed	✅ green
01-03-T3	03	2	CORE-09, CORE-04	T-01-02	Base64 codec with 50MB DoS cap + full round-trip	unit + integration	npx vitest run src/save/round-trip.test.ts && npm run build	✓ committed	✅ green
01-04-T1	04	2	PIPE-01, STRY-09	—	Vite-native loader + Zod schemas + demo fragment	smoke	npm run build && npm run compile:ink	✓ committed	✅ green
01-04-T2	04	2	PIPE-01	—	Schema violation throws (build fails on bad content)	unit	npx vitest run src/content/loader.test.ts	✓ committed	✅ green
01-05-T1	05	2	PIPE-03, AEST-08, AEST-09	T-01-06, T-01-07	Validator script + sidecar schema + refused-sample fixture (test fixture isolated under os.tmpdir())	integration	node scripts/validate-assets.mjs && npx vitest run scripts/validate-assets.test.ts	✓ committed	✅ green
01-05-T2	05	2	AEST-08, AEST-09	T-01-06	10–20 north-star reference images committed with sidecars	manual + smoke	node scripts/validate-assets.mjs (count assertion)	⚠ partial	⬜ pending (checkpoint:human-verify — awaiting human curation; validator passes with 0 assets, will continue passing once images land with sidecars)
01-06-T1	06	2	PIPE-05, UX-13	—	anti-FOMO doctrine consolidates 4 source documents (file exists with required H2 sections)	smoke	test -f .planning/anti-fomo-doctrine.md && grep -q '## Banned Mechanics' .planning/anti-fomo-doctrine.md	✓ committed	✅ green
01-06-T2	06	2	PIPE-05, STRY-09	—	Season 7 end-state doctrine principle-level + doc-lint test	doc-lint	npx vitest run scripts/doctrine.test.ts	✓ committed	✅ green
01-07-T1	07	3	PIPE-06	T-01-08	GitHub Actions workflow runs npm run ci on push + PR	smoke (CI)	npm run ci (locally) + workflow runs on next push	✓ committed	✅ green (local npm run ci exits 0 immediately before commit; GitHub-side workflow validation occurs on next push to main)

Status: ⬜ pending · ✅ green · ❌ red · ⚠️ flaky

Coverage: All 16 Phase-1 requirement IDs (CORE-01, CORE-04, CORE-05, CORE-06, CORE-07, CORE-08, CORE-09, CORE-10, PIPE-01, PIPE-03, PIPE-05, PIPE-06, AEST-08, AEST-09, STRY-09, UX-13) are covered by at least one task above.

---

Per-Requirement Behavior Map (from RESEARCH.md)

Req ID	Behavior Under Test	Test Type	Automated Command	Plan
CORE-04	IndexedDB save round-trips AND localStorage fallback round-trips when IDB rejects (stub-injected)	unit	npx vitest run src/save/db.test.ts	03
CORE-05	requestPersistence() returns {granted, apiAvailable} shape and handles missing API	unit	npx vitest run src/save/persist.test.ts	03
CORE-06	wrap() produces valid envelope; unwrap() rejects checksum mismatch	unit	npx vitest run src/save/envelope.test.ts	03
CORE-07	migrate({garden:[]}, 0) produces v1 shape; migrations[1] invoked exactly once	unit	npx vitest run src/save/migrations.test.ts	03
CORE-08	After 5 successive snapshot() calls, exactly 3 newest entries remain	unit	npx vitest run src/save/snapshots.test.ts	03
CORE-09	Base64 export → import → migrate → unwrap yields original payload	unit (round-trip)	npx vitest run src/save/round-trip.test.ts	03
CORE-10	src/sim/ importing from src/render/ produces ESLint error	static-analysis	npx vitest run src/sim/__test_violation__/lint-firewall.test.ts (programmatic ESLint API)	02
CORE-01	Game scaffold npm run build produces a valid bundle	smoke	npm run build (Phase 2 PIPE-07 adds Playwright)	01
PIPE-01	Demo content file with deliberate schema violation fails the build	unit (build-time)	npx vitest run src/content/loader.test.ts	04
PIPE-03	Asset validator script exits non-zero on a fixture missing provenance (fixture isolated under os.tmpdir())	integration	npx vitest run scripts/validate-assets.test.ts	05
PIPE-05	.planning/anti-fomo-doctrine.md and .planning/season-7-end-state.md exist with required H2 sections	doc lint	npx vitest run scripts/doctrine.test.ts	06
PIPE-06	All save migration tests run on every CI build	meta	.github/workflows/ci.yml runs npm run ci	07
AEST-08 / AEST-09	All assets in assets/ (excluding __samples__/refused/) have valid provenance sidecars	integration	covered by PIPE-03 test + Plan 05 north-star commit	05
STRY-09	Vacuously satisfied: Phase 1 ships no source code containing player-visible strings; first enforcement lands in Phase 2	n/a (Phase 1 has no code to externalize from yet)	—	04, 06
UX-13	Doctrine doc enforced by review per CONTEXT D-07	manual-only	—	06

Note on STRY-09 (BLOCKER 4 fix): STRY-09 ("All player-visible strings externalized to /content/, never hardcoded in source") is vacuously satisfied in Phase 1 — Phase 1 ships scaffolding, doctrine docs, and pure-function libraries (save layer, content loader, asset validator); none of these contain player-visible UI strings. The /content/ convention is established by Plan 04's loader + demo fragment + README, and the <content/> directory tree is committed by Plans 01 and 04, but no source code yet exists that could hardcode a player-visible string. First enforcement (lint rule on JSX text nodes, or grep guard) lands in Phase 2 when the first UI components are authored. This row previously cited CONTEXT D-07 erroneously (D-07 is about anti-FOMO review enforcement, not about UX-string externalization) — that misattribution is corrected here.

---

Wave 0 Requirements

Wave 0 (test infrastructure) is split across Plans 01 and the test files of Plans 02–06:

• vitest.config.ts — minimal happy-dom config (Plan 01 Task 2)
• playwright.config.ts — installed only, no specs in Phase 1 (Plan 01 Task 2)
• eslint.config.js — flat config with eslint-plugin-boundaries (Plan 02 Task 1)
• src/sim/__test_violation__/violator.ts — boundary lint fixture (Plan 02 Task 2)
• src/sim/__test_violation__/lint-firewall.test.ts — boundary rule assertion (Plan 02 Task 2)
• src/save/checksum.test.ts — checksum determinism (Plan 03 Task 1)
• src/save/envelope.test.ts — CORE-06 (Plan 03 Task 1)
• src/save/migrations.test.ts — CORE-07 (Plan 03 Task 1)
• src/save/db.test.ts — CORE-04 (IDB-primary + LocalStorageDBAdapter fallback paths) (Plan 03 Task 2)
• src/save/snapshots.test.ts — CORE-08 (Plan 03 Task 2)
• src/save/persist.test.ts — CORE-05 (Plan 03 Task 2)
• src/save/round-trip.test.ts — CORE-09 (Plan 03 Task 3)
• src/content/loader.test.ts — PIPE-01 (Plan 04 Task 2)
• scripts/validate-assets.test.ts — PIPE-03 (Plan 05 Task 1, fixture isolated under os.tmpdir())
• scripts/doctrine.test.ts — PIPE-05 (Plan 06 Task 2)
• .github/workflows/ci.yml — runs npm run ci on PR + push (Plan 07 Task 1)
• Framework install: vitest, happy-dom, fake-indexeddb, @playwright/test (all installed by Plan 01 Task 1)

[x] indicates the plan ships the file; actual file creation happens during execution.

---

Manual-Only Verifications

Behavior	Requirement	Why Manual	Test Instructions
Game scaffold loads in Chrome/Firefox/Safari/Edge under 5s on 25 Mbps	CORE-01	Multi-browser load-time + bandwidth simulation belongs in Phase 2 Playwright (PIPE-07); Phase 1 ships the bundle and verifies build succeeds	Run npm run build && npm run preview, open in each browser locally, confirm load. Cross-browser perf gate is Phase 2's gsd-verify-work deliverable.
Anti-FOMO doctrine review-readiness	UX-13	Doctrine is enforced by human review per CONTEXT D-07; no lint rule	Read .planning/anti-fomo-doctrine.md end-to-end; confirm every banned pattern from PROJECT.md / REQUIREMENTS.md / CLAUDE.md / PITFALLS.md #9 is enumerated.
Season 7 end-state principle clarity	STRY-09 (related; not the formal target — see note above)	Principle-level doc; enforced by review	Read .planning/season-7-end-state.md; confirm it answers (a) what rest state means, (b) what the finite Roothold ceiling is tied to, (c) the coda's tonal register.
North-star reference set human-curation	AEST-09	Curation gate is the human reviewer per CONTEXT D-03	Manually review the 10–20 generations under assets/north-stars/; confirm provenance sidecars present and visually consistent. (Plan 05 Task 2 is checkpoint:human-verify.)

---

Validation Sign-Off

• All tasks have <automated> verify or Wave 0 dependencies (Plan 05 Task 2 is the sole checkpoint:human-verify per CONTEXT D-01 + D-03 — curation gate is human review by design)
• Sampling continuity: no 3 consecutive tasks without automated verify (every plan has at least one automated test except Plan 05 T2 which is the human-curation checkpoint)
• Wave 0 covers all MISSING references — see "Wave 0 Requirements" above
• No watch-mode flags — npm test uses vitest run (one-shot)
• Feedback latency < 30s — npm run ci is ~30s per RESEARCH § Validation Architecture
• nyquist_compliant: true set in frontmatter

Approval: approved